Genotoxicity test of eight natural color additives in the Korean market

Various natural color additives are preferred by many consumers over synthetic color additives because they are perceived to be safer. However, most do not have sufficient toxicity data for safety assurance. Color ingredients in particular have some structures suspected of being toxic. Eight natural color additives, gardenia red, blue, and yellow; lac color; cochineal extract; beet red; Curcuma longa Linne extract (Curcuma extract); and Monascus red, currently permitted for use in Korea, were selected and subjected to genotoxicity tests. Acceptable daily intake values have not been allocated to these color additives (except for cochineal extract) due to the lack of toxicity data. We used genotoxicity testing-the bacterial reverse mutation test (Ames test), in vitro mammalian chromosomal aberration test, and in vivo alkaline comet test-for minimum safety assurance.

Six out of eight food colorants did not cause genotoxicity and cytotoxicity. However, Monascus red and Curcuma extract showed definite cytotoxicity and probable genotoxicity.

Gardenia red and blue, cochineal extract, lac color, and beet red did not induce mutagenicity or chromosomal abnormalities. Gardenia yellow was mutagenic in the Ames test, but was not positive in the in vitro chromosomal aberration test or in vivo alkaline comet assay. Curcuma extract and Monascus red induced cytotoxicity in the Ames test at high concentrations in Salmonella typhimurium TA1537 and TA100, without showing mutagenicity. On cytotoxicity testing, Curcuma extract and Monascus red showed cytotoxicity at concentrations higher than 313 μg/ml in Chinese hamster ovary CHO-K1 cells and showed equivocal results in chromosomal aberration assay of the same cells. Curcuma extract and Monascus red produced significant increases in DNA damage at a dose of 2000 mg/kg b.w./day, and induced dose-dependent increases in % DNA in the tail and tail moment on in vivo comet assay. Conclusions: Six out of eight food colorants did not cause genotoxicity and cytotoxicity. However, Monascus red and Curcuma extract showed definite cytotoxicity and probable genotoxicity.