Arsenic effectively treats acute promyelocytic leukemia by inducing SUMO and ubiquitin-dependent degradation of the promyelocytic leukemia (PML)-retinoic acid receptor alpha oncogenic fusion protein. However, some patients relapse with arsenic-resistant disease because of missense mutations in PML. To determine the mechanistic basis for arsenic resistance, PML-/- cells were reconstituted with YFP fusions of wild-type PML-V and two common patient mutants: A216T and L217F. Both mutants were resistant to degradation by arsenic but for different biochemical reasons. Arsenic did not trigger SUMOylation of A216T PML, which failed to recruit the SUMO-targeting ubiquitin ligases RNF4 and TOPORS. L217F PML did respond with increased SUMO2/3 conjugation that facilitated RNF4 engagement but failed to reach the threshold of SUMO1 conjugation required to recruit TOPORS. Thus, neither mutant accumulated the appropriate polyubiquitin signal required for p97 binding. These PML mutants have revealed a convergence of SUMO1, SUMO2/3, TOPORS, and RNF4 that facilitates the arsenic-induced degradation of PML.