Many diseases are related to multiple genetic alterations within a single gene. Probing for highly multiple (>10) variants in a single quantitative PCR tube is impossible because of a limited number of fluorescence channels and the limited ability to test one variant per channel, increasing the need for tubes. Herein, a novel color-mixing strategy was experimentally validated that uses fluorescence combinations as digital color codes to probe multiple variants simultaneously. The color-mixing strategy relies on a simple intratube assay that can probe for 15 variants as part of an intertube assay that can probe for an exponentially increased number of variants. This strategy is achieved by using multiplex double-stranded toehold probes modified with fluorophores and quenchers; the probes are designed to be quenched or remain luminous after binding to wild-type or variant templates. The color-mixing strategy was used to probe for 21 pathogenic variants in thalassemia and to distinguish between heterozygous and homozygous variants in six tubes, with a specificity of 99% and a sensitivity of 94%. To support tuberculosis diagnosis, the same strategy was applied to simultaneously probe in Mycobacterium tuberculosis for rifampicin-resistance mutations occurring within one 81-bp region and one 48-bp region in the rpoB gene, plus five isoniazid-resistance mutations in the inhA and katG genes.