A Comparison of the Molecular Pharmacological Properties of Current Short, Long, and Ultra-Long-Acting β(2)-Agonists Used for Asthma and COPD.

β-agonists have been used in asthma for 120 years. There are two recent changes: ultra-long-acting agonists for COPD and new asthma guidelines recommending formoterol/ICS inhalers phasing out short-acting salbutamol inhalers. Few studies directly compare the molecular pharmacological properties of short (salbutamol, terbutaline, fenoterol), long (formoterol, salmeterol), and ultra-long-acting (indacaterol, olodaterol, vilanterol) β(2)-agonists. Here, the in vitro molecular pharmacological properties of affinity, selectivity, intrinsic efficacy, and duration of β(2)-agonists at human β(2) and β(1)-adrenoceptors and the 4 β(2)-polymorphisms stably expressed in CHO cells were directly compared using radioligand binding and functional studies. Whilst short-acting drugs were similar, there was huge variation and complete overlap in the molecular pharmacological properties of drugs labeled as long and ultra-long-acting β(2)-agonists. Salmeterol and vilanterol were highly β(2)-selective (> 1000-fold) whereas indacaterol was similar to salbutamol (40-fold). Formoterol and indacaterol were the most efficacious, whereas salmeterol had the longest duration of binding. Salmeterol and vilanterol utilize a β(2)-specific exosite (β(2)-H296-K305) for high affinity and selectivity (that does not affect intrinsic efficacy or duration) whilst the β(2)-selectivity of formoterol and olodaterol resides elsewhere. Duration of binding closely correlated with lipophilicity. β(2)-polymorphisms had no substantial effect on β(2)-agonist properties. Comparison with other β-ligands suggests that affinity and duration could both be improved further. However, given the very wide range of molecular pharmacological properties of β-agonists that are clinically effective and widely used, non-pharmacological properties (physiochemical, patient factors, devices and combination inhaler availability) may be as important in final clinical patient outcomes as the molecular pharmacological properties of the individual β(2)-agonists themselves.