Analyzing the performance of multimodal large language models on visually-based questions in the Japanese National Examination for Dental Technicians

分析多模态大型语言模型在日本国家牙科技师考试中基于视觉的问题上的表现

阅读:1

Abstract

BACKGROUND/PURPOSE: Large language models (LLMs) offer promising applications in dentistry, but their performance in specialized, image-rich contexts such as dental technology examinations remains uncertain. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the accuracy of three multimodal LLMs, ChatGPT-4o (4o), OpenAI o1 (o1), and Claude 3.5 Sonnet (Sonnet), when presented with questions from the Japanese National Examination for Dental Technicians. MATERIALS AND METHODS: A total of 240 multiple-choice questions from 2022 to 2024 theory sections of the exam were used. Each question, including its accompanying figures or images where applicable, was presented to the three LLMs in a zero-shot manner without specialized prompting. Correct response rates were calculated overall, as well as by question type (text-only vs. visually-based) and subject area. Statistical comparisons were performed using Cochran's Q test, followed by McNemar's test with Bonferroni correction where indicated. RESULTS: Overall correct response rates were 58.3 % (4o), 67.5 % (o1), and 64.6 % (Claude 3.5 Sonnet). For text-only questions, o1 achieved the highest accuracy (79.1 %), significantly outperforming 4o (68.3 %; P = 0.017). In contrast, all models showed reduced accuracy on visually-based questions (44.6-55.4 %), with no significant difference among them. CONCLUSION: These results suggest that multimodal LLMs can supplement theoretical dental technology education, although their limited performance on visual tasks indicates the need for traditional hands-on training. Enhanced image interpretation skills may help address workforce challenges in dental technology.

特别声明

1、本页面内容包含部分的内容是基于公开信息的合理引用;引用内容仅为补充信息,不代表本站立场。

2、若认为本页面引用内容涉及侵权,请及时与本站联系,我们将第一时间处理。

3、其他媒体/个人如需使用本页面原创内容,需注明“来源:[生知库]”并获得授权;使用引用内容的,需自行联系原作者获得许可。

4、投稿及合作请联系:info@biocloudy.com。