Abstract
Many non-natural amino acids can be incorporated by biological systems into coded functional peptides and proteins. For such incorporations to be effective, they must not only be compatible with the desired function but also evade various biochemical error-checking mechanisms. The underlying molecular mechanisms are complex, and this problem has been approached previously largely by expert perception of isomer compatibility, followed by empirical study. However, the number of amino acids that might be incorporable by the biological coding machinery may be too large to survey efficiently using such an intuitive approach. We introduce here a workflow for searching real and computed non-natural amino acid libraries for biosimilar amino acids which may be incorporable into coded proteins with minimal unintended disturbance of function. This workflow was also applied to molecules which have been previously benchmarked for their compatibility with the biological translation apparatus, as well as commercial catalogs. We report the results of scoring their contents based on fingerprint similarity via Tanimoto coefficients. These similarity scoring methods reveal candidate amino acids which could be substitutable into modern proteins. Our analysis discovers some already-implemented substitutions, but also suggests many novel ones.