Abstract
Silver nanoparticles (AgNPs) are known to affect the physiology and morphology of plants in various ways, but the exact mechanism by which they interact with plant cells remains to be elucidated. An unresolved question of silver nanotoxicology is whether the interaction is triggered by the physical features of the particles, or by silver ions leached from their surface. In this study, we germinated and grew Arabidopsis thaliana seedlings in synthetic medium supplemented with sub-morbid concentrations (4 μg/mL) of AgNPs and silver nitrate (AgNO(3)). This treatment led to in planta accumulation of 106 μg/g and 97 μg/g of silver in the AgNO(3)- and AgNP-exposed seedlings, respectively. Despite the statistically indistinguishable silver accumulation, RNA sequencing data demonstrated distinct changes in the transcriptome of the AgNP-exposed, but not in the AgNO(3)-exposed plants. AgNP exposure induced changes in the expression of genes involved in immune response, cell wall organization, photosynthesis and cellular defense against reactive oxygen species. AgNO(3) exposure, on the other hand, caused the differential expression of only two genes, neither of which belonged to any AgNP-enriched gene ontology categories. Moreover, AgNP exposure led to a 39% reduction (p < 0.001) in total chlorophyll concentration relative to untreated plants which was associated with a 56.9% and 56.2% drop (p < 0.05) in carbon assimilation rate at ambient and saturating light, respectively. Stomatal conductance was not significantly affected by AgNP exposure, and limitations to carbon assimilation, as determined through analysis of light and carbon dioxide (A/Ci) curves, were attributed to rates of electron transport, maximum carboxylation rates and triose phosphate use. AgNO(3)-exposure, on the other hand, did not lead to significant reduction either in chlorophyll concentration or in carbon assimilation rate. Given these data, we propose that the impact of AgNPs cannot be simply attributed to the presence of the metal in plants, but is innate to the particulate nature of nanosilver.