Abstract
BACKGROUND: 'Next-generation' (NGS) sequencing has wide application in medical genetics, including the detection of somatic variation in cancer. The Ion Torrent-based (IONT) platform is among NGS technologies employed in clinical, research and diagnostic settings. However, identifying mutations from IONT deep sequencing with high confidence has remained a challenge. We compared various computational variant-calling methods to derive a variant identification pipeline that may improve the molecular diagnostic and research utility of IONT. RESULTS: Using IONT, we surveyed variants from the 409-gene Comprehensive Cancer Panel in whole-section tumors, intra-tumoral biopsies and matched normal samples obtained from frozen tissues and blood from four early-stage non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) patients. We used MuTect, Varscan2, IONT's proprietary Ion Reporter, and a simple subtraction we called "Poor Man's Caller." Together these produced calls at 637 loci across all samples. Visual validation of 434 called variants was performed, and performance of the methods assessed individually and in combination. Of the subset of inspected putative variant calls (n=223) in genomic regions that were not intronic or intergenic, 68 variants (30%) were deemed valid after visual inspection. Among the individual methods, the Ion Reporter method offered perhaps the most reasonable tradeoffs. Ion Reporter captured 83% of all discovered variants; 50% of its variants were visually validated. Aggregating results from multiple packages offered varied improvements in performance. CONCLUSIONS: Overall, Ion Reporter offered the most attractive performance among the individual callers. This study suggests combined strategies to maximize sensitivity and positive predictive value in variant calling using IONT deep sequencing.