Abstract
The genetic heterogeneity of HIV-1 poses a major obstacle to vaccine development. Although most horizontally acquired HIV-1 infections are initiated by a single homogeneous virus, marked genetic diversification and evolution occur following transmission. The relative contribution of the antiviral immune response to intrahost viral evolution remains controversial, in part because the sequence of the transmitted virus and the array of T-cell epitopes targeted by both donor and recipient are seldom known. We directly compared predominant viral sequences derived from 52 mother-child transmission pairs following vertical infection and identified 1,475 sites of mother-infant amino acid divergence within Nef, Gag, and Pol. The cumulative number of mutations away from the consensus subtype B sequence increased linearly with time since transmission, whereas reversions toward the consensus sequence accumulated more slowly with increasing duration of infection. Comprehensive mapping of T-cell epitopes targeted by these mothers and infants revealed that 14% of nonsynonymous mutations away from the consensus sequence were located within regions targeted by the infant, whereas 24% of nonsynonymous mutations toward the consensus sequence were located in regions targeted by the mother. On the basis of analysis of optimal epitopes listed in the HIV Molecular Immunology Database, fewer than 10% of epitopes containing maternal escape mutations reverted to the consensus sequence following transmission to an infant lacking the restricting HLA allele. This surprisingly low reversion rate of mutated epitopes following transmission suggests that the fitness cost associated with many CD8 epitope mutations may be modest.