Abstract
Molecular dynamics simulations are used extensively to study the processes on biological membranes. The simulations can be conducted at different levels of resolution: all atom (AA), where all atomistic details are provided; united atom (UA), where hydrogen atoms are treated inseparably of corresponding heavy atoms; and coarse grained (CG), where atoms are grouped into larger particles. Here, we study the behavior of model bilayers consisting of saturated and unsaturated lipids DOPC, SOPC, OSPC and DSPC in simulations performed using all atom CHARMM36 and coarse grained Martini force fields. Using principal components analysis, we show that the structural and dynamical properties of the lipids are similar, both in AA and CG simulations, although the unsaturated molecules are more dynamic and favor more extended conformations. We find that CG simulations capture 75 to 100% of the major collective motions, overestimate short range ordering, result in more flexible molecules and 5-7 fold faster sampling. We expect that the results reported here will be useful for comprehensive quantitative comparisons of simulations conducted at different resolution levels and for further development and improvement of CG force fields.