Abstract
Why autoantibodies in rheumatoid arthritis (RA) primarily target physiologically modified proteins, called citrullinated proteins, is unknown. Recognizing the inciting event in the production of anti-citrullinated protein antibodies (ACPAs) may shed light on the origin of RA. Here, we demonstrate that ACPAs originate from germline-encoded antibodies targeting a distinct but structurally similar modification, called carbamylation, which is pathogenic and environmentally driven. The transition from anti-carbamylated protein (anti-CarP) antibodies to ACPAs results from somatic hypermutations, indicating that the change in reactivity is acquired via antigen-driven affinity maturation. During this process, a single germline anti-CarP antibody transitions from anti-CarP to double positive (anti-CarP/ACPA) to ACPA according to the pattern and number of somatic hypermutations, explaining their coexistence and diverse specificity in RA. Artificial intelligence-based structural modeling revealed that an ACPA and its germline precursor exhibit distinct structural and biophysical properties, and pointed to heavy-chain tryptophan 48 (H-W48) as a critical residue in the differential recognition of citrullinated vs. carbamylated proteins. Indeed, a single methionine substitution in H-W48 changes the antibody specificity from ACPA to anti-CarP. These data indicate that the existence of germline-encoded anti-CarP antibodies is most likely the first event in the production of ACPAs during the early stages of RA development.