Abstract
Introduction Subsequent anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injury is more common in the pediatric population and encompasses graft failure and subsequent contralateral tears. Females are at a higher risk. The purpose of the present study was to compare the knee valgus angles at initial contact, knee extension moments, anterior and lateral knee joint forces, hip flexion angles, hip adduction moments, and ankle inversion during the drop vertical test in the uninjured extremity between adolescent males and females who had previously undergone an anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR). Methods This IRB-approved retrospective chart review included patients aged 8-18 years who were seen at the five to seven month postoperatively following ACL reconstruction. A total of 168 patients met our inclusion criteria (86 girls and 82 boys.) Using three-dimensional motion capture technology (CORTEX software, Motion Analysis Corp., Rohnert Park, CA), data were collected while the subject performed the drop vertical test over floor-mounted force plates (FP-Stairs, AMTI, Watertown, MA) under the direct supervision of a pediatric physical therapist. The Wilcoxon rank sum was used, and p < 0.05 was considered statistically significant. Results Females demonstrated a larger average knee joint extension moment (0.31 vs 0.28 N*m/kg, p = 0.0408), a larger anterior knee joint force at initial contact (3.51 vs. 2.79, N/kg, p = 0.0458), larger average hip flexion angle (41.50° vs. 35.99°, p = 0.0005), a smaller maximum hip adduction moment (0.92 vs. 1.16, N*m/kg, p = 0.0497), and a smaller average ankle inversion angle (5.08° vs. 6.41°, p = 0.03231). No significant differences were found regarding knee abduction angle or lateral knee joint force. Conclusions The biomechanical profile of the contralateral extremity varies significantly between the genders after ACLR. In the uninjured extremity, females may have larger hip flexion angles, smaller hip adduction moments, larger anterior knee joint forces, larger knee extension moments, and smaller ankle inversion angles as compared to males after ACLR. These findings may explain the higher incidence of subsequent contralateral injury in female adolescent athletes. Further work is required to develop a composite score that determines at-risk athletes.