Abstract
The proapoptotic effects of the Bcl-2 antagonist HA14-1 are believed to derive from its affinity for the hydrophobic groove on Bcl-2 and Bcl-x(L), thereby displacing proapoptotic factors, e.g. Bax and Bak. We have reported that HA14-1 promotes the efficacy of low-dose photodynamic therapy (PDT). A recent report proposed that the proapoptotic activity of HA14-1 reflects its ability to generate reactive oxygen species (ROS) when incubated in an aqueous environment. This later study, like several other HA14-1 investigations, relied on the use of fluorescent probes for ROS detection. We found that HA14-1 reacts with the albumin in serum to yield a fluorescent product. After correcting for this effect, the putative formation of ROS by HA14-1 could not be demonstrated with the fluorescent probes H(2)DCFDA, dihydroethidium or dihydrorhodamine. Indeed, the fluorescence excitation/emission spectra of HA14-1 encompassed the excitation/emission wavelengths used to detect these ROS probes. Cells cultured in a medium supplemented with ovalbumin, instead of serum, underwent apoptosis following HA14-1 addition, but did not exhibit fluorescence. Hence, HA14-1 fluorescence was unrelated to its proapoptotic activity. We conclude that the enhancement of PDT by HA14-1 reflects a pharmacologic effect, rather than its direct contribution of ROS.