Abstract
STUDY OBJECTIVE: To establish face and construct validity for a novel variation of American College of Obstetrics and Gynecology "Flowerpot Model" for transvaginal hysterectomy (TVH) surgical simulation with improved vesicovaginal dissection during surgical education simulation. DESIGN: Cross-sectional face and construct validation study using the "Flowerpot Model." The vesicovaginal dissection plane was modified to include additional felt and balloon materials to simulate the bladder. SETTING: Single academic center. PARTICIPANTS: Fourteen residents and fellows, postgraduate year (PGY) 2 to 6, subdivided into junior (n = 8) with ≤10 prior TVH surgeries and senior groups (n = 6) with >10 prior TVH surgeries performed. INTERVENTIONS: All subjects watched a brief introductory video and then were filmed simulating a TVH. MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS: For face validity, subjects completed an anatomic checklist and pre/post simulation satisfaction survey. For construct validation, 2 independent, blinded expert surgeons (M.A. and J.M.) graded films using the Global Rating Scale of Operative Performance (GRS). Primary outcome was mean GRS between groups. The junior group consisted of PGY 2 to 3 with ≤ 10 prior TVH, median 7.5 (interquartile range [IQR] 6.75) and senior group PGY 3 to 6 with >10 TVH, median 19 (IQR 10) (p <.01). Subjects were "satisfied" or "very satisfied" with bladder and anterior peritoneal fold simulation (92%) and found vesicovaginal dissection "realistic" (100%). GRS score was significantly different between groups (juniors, 19.5 [IQR 5] vs seniors, 28.5 [IQR 8.5]; p = .048). Intergrader correlation was high (ρ = 0.87, p <.01). Surgeon volume of prior TVH was not significantly correlated to average GRS score, ρ = 0.49 (p = .10). The model improved comfort and confidence scores in the junior group more than senior group (p = .04), but senior group still had higher post simulation confidence scores than the junior group (p = .02). CONCLUSION: Face and construct validity with the modified Flowerpot Model was demonstrated. This low fidelity model is capable of simulation of a TVH with a novel vesicovaginal dissection. Prior surgical experience was not correlated to GRS score or time to procedure completion.