Abstract
Mesothelin targeting CAR T cells have limited activity in patients. In this study, we sought to determine if efficacy of anti-mesothelin CAR T cells is dependent on the mesothelin epitopes that are recognized by them. To do so, we developed hYP218 (against membrane-proximal epitope) and SS1 (against membrane-distal epitope) CAR T cells. Their efficacy was assessed in vitro using mesothelin-positive tumor cell lines and in vivo in NSG mice with mesothelin-expressing ovarian cancer (OVCAR-8), pancreatic cancer (KLM-1), and mesothelioma patient-derived (NCI-Meso63) tumor xenografts. Persistence and tumor infiltration of CAR T cells was determined using flow cytometry. hYP218 CAR T cells killed cancer cells more efficiently than SS1 CAR T cells, with a two- to fourfold lower ET50 value (effector-to-target ratio for 50% killing of tumor cells). In mice with established tumors, single intravenous administration of hYP218 CAR T cells lead to improved tumor response and survival compared with SS1 CAR T cells, with complete regression of OVCAR-8 and NCI-Meso63 tumors. Compared with SS1 CAR T cells, there was increased peripheral blood expansion, persistence, and tumor infiltration of hYP218 CAR T cells in the KLM-1 tumor model. Persistence of hYP218 CAR T cells in treated mice led to antitumor immunity when rechallenged with KLM-1 tumor cells. Our results show that hYP218 CAR T cells, targeting mesothelin epitope close to cell membrane, are very effective against mesothelin-positive tumors and are associated with increased persistence and tumor infiltration. These results support its clinical development to treat patients with mesothelin-expressing cancers.