Abstract
This study aimed to evaluate fatigue of three stent designs when various forces are applied and perform a comparative analyses. A computer simulation using the finite element method was performed. In particular, we constructed a three-dimensional finite element model of nitinol stents with three designs (S6: single-woven wire, wire diameter: 0.006 inch; D6: double-woven wire, wire diameter: 0.006 inch, and D7: double-woven wire, wire diameter: 0.007 inch) that are used to treat canine tracheal collapse (TC). The stents were subjected to a 200 mmHg compression force, a pure torsion force in a perpendicular direction, and a bending-torsion force combining perpendicular and axial forces. The von Mises stress was calculated to evaluate the extent of stent displacement, and Goodman diagrams were plotted to compare fatigue life cycles. D7 exhibited a longer fatigue life compared to S6 and D6. Under compression, pure torsion, and bending-torsion forces, displacement was the smallest for D7, followed by D6 and S6. Similarly, the fatigue life was the longest for D7, followed by D6 and S6. S6 showed the greatest displacement when subjected to external forces; among stents designed using the same wire, D6 displayed less displacement than S6, and D7 exhibited superior fatigue life when subjected to varying degrees of force. This study showed that the structural stability and fatigue life of stents could be effectively compared using finite element method D7 has the greatest stability and structural rigidity under cyclic load.