From stakeholder mapping to statistical modeling: an illustrative demonstration of end-to-end Net-Map methodology for health governance analysis

从利益相关者映射到统计建模:以端到端网络映射方法论为例,展示其在卫生治理分析中的应用

阅读:1

Abstract

BACKGROUND: Coordinating primary cancer prevention in Europe requires alignment across the EU, national, and local actors. Yet governance relations are challenging to observe. We used a participatory network approach to make relationships visible and test which ties are associated with funding. This study serves as a methodological demonstration to illustrate the complete Net-Map research cycle from data collection to statistical analysis. METHODS: Three Net-Map sessions (January-February 2024) with a national NGO expert panel elicited stakeholders and ties for authority, influence, and funding, followed by validation. Canvases were used to record the information, and they were digitized afterwards into edge and attribute files. We described network structure and estimated four nested exponential random graph models (ERGMs) for the directed funding network, progressively adding governance level (EU, national, local), formal authority, and informal influence as predictors of tie formation. Model diagnostics included goodness-of-fit assessment, structural extensions controlling for degree heterogeneity and clustering, and robustness checks across network subsets. RESULTS: The final network comprises 128 organizations and 836 funding ties (density 5.14%). Funding is predominantly cross-level (71.4%). EU actors show the strongest outward activity (EU-national density 17.8%; EU-local 16.1%), while national-local is lower (6.2%). In ERGMs, influence is the strongest correlate of funding (OR 168.54, p < 0.001), authority is positive but smaller (OR 5.76, p < 0.001), and same-level funding is less likely (OR 0.35, p < 0.001). Model comparisons favored the full specification. Goodness-of-fit diagnostics were adequate for the modeled dyadic statistics. Supplementary structural extensions controlling for degree heterogeneity and clustering attenuate the influence OR to 41.49, while the authority OR remains stable (5.76–6.46), confirming that both effects are robust to model specification. CONCLUSIONS: This illustrative analysis claims that participatory Net-Map workshops, combined with formal network analysis are helpful in diagnosing coordination patterns in decentralized health systems. The findings suggest that authority and influence serve complementary functions in governance, with implications that warrant further investigation with broader panels and longitudinal designs. The results primarily serve as an example of methodological application rather than providing generalizable insights about Romanian cancer prevention governance. SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s13690-026-01879-2.

特别声明

1、本页面内容包含部分的内容是基于公开信息的合理引用;引用内容仅为补充信息,不代表本站立场。

2、若认为本页面引用内容涉及侵权,请及时与本站联系,我们将第一时间处理。

3、其他媒体/个人如需使用本页面原创内容,需注明“来源:[生知库]”并获得授权;使用引用内容的,需自行联系原作者获得许可。

4、投稿及合作请联系:info@biocloudy.com。