Abstract
Metabolic syndrome (MetS) associated with Osteoarthritis (OA) is an increasingly recognised entity. Whilst the degenerative pattern in cuff-tear arthropathy (CTA) has been well documented, the biological processes behind primary shoulder OA and CTA remain less understood. This study investigates transcriptomic differences in these conditions, alongside the impact of MetS in patients undergoing total shoulder replacement. In a multi-centre study, 20 OA patients undergoing total shoulder replacement were included based on specific treatment indications for OA and cuff-tear arthropathy as well as 25 patients undergoing rotator cuff repair (RCR) as a comparator group. Tissues from subchondral bone, capsule (OA and RCR), and synovium were biopsied, and RNA sequencing was performed using Illumina platforms. Differential gene expression was conducted using DESeq2, adjusting for demographic factors, followed by pathway enrichment using the mitch package. Gene expressions in CTA and primary OA was differentially affected. CTA showed mitochondrial dysfunction, GATD3A downregulation, and increased cartilage degradation, while primary OA was marked by upregulated inflammatory and catabolic pathways. The effect of MetS on these pathologies was further shown. MetS further disrupted WNT/β-catenin signalling in CTA, and in OA. Genes such as ACAN, PANX3, CLU, and VAT1L were upregulated, highlighting potential biomarkers for early OA detection. This transcriptomic analysis reveals key differences between end-stage CTA and primary glenohumeral OA. CTA shows heightened metabolic/protein synthesis activity with less immune-driven inflammation. Under MetS, mitochondrial dysfunction (including GATD3A downregulation) and altered Wnt/β-catenin signalling intensify cartilage and bone damage. In contrast, primary OA features strong complement activation, inflammatory gene expression, and collagen remodelling. MetS worsens both conditions via oxidative stress, advanced glycation end products, and ECM disruption-particularly, increased CS/DS degradation. These distinctions support targeted treatments, from antioxidants and Wnt modulators to aggrecanase inhibitors or clusterin augmentation. Addressing specific molecular disruptions, especially those amplified by MetS, may preserve shoulder function, delay surgical intervention, and improve long-term patient outcomes.