Abstract
In thumb carpometacarpal (CMC) instability, laxity of the ligaments surrounding the joint leads to pain and weakness in grip and pinch strength, which predisposes the patient to developing CMC joint arthritis. Recent advancements in joint anatomy and kinematics have led to the development of various surgical reconstructive procedures. This systematic review outlines the available ligament reconstruction techniques and their efficacy in treating nontraumatic and nonarthritic CMC instability. Additionally, we aimed to provide evidence which specific ligament reconstruction technique demonstrates the best results. Four databases (Embase, MEDLINE, Web of Science, and Cochrane Central) were searched for studies that reported on surgical techniques and their clinical outcomes in patients with nontraumatic and nonarthritic CMC instability. Twelve studies were analyzed for qualitative review, including nine different surgical ligament reconstruction techniques involving two hundred and thirty thumbs. All but one of the reported techniques improved postoperative pain scores and showed substantial improvement in pinch and grip strength. Complication rates varied between 0% and 25%. The included studies showed that ligament reconstruction effectively alleviated the patients' complaints regarding pain and instability, resulting in overall high patient satisfaction. Nevertheless, drawing definitive conclusions regarding the superiority of any ligament reconstruction technique remains challenging owing to the limited availability of homogeneous data in the current literature.