Abstract
The health consequences associated with using electronic cigarettes (ECs) are of great public interest because of their potential role in smoking cessation. In 110 participants, including 41 nonusers, 34 people who exclusively use ECs (EC group), and 35 people who smoke tobacco cigarettes (TCs) including 12 dual users (collectively called the TC-D group), the heart rate (HR), blood pressure (BP), and heart rate variability (HRV) were compared at baseline. People in the EC or the TC-D groups were also compared after using a 4th generation EC with or without nicotine, a TC with or without nicotine (TC-D group only), and a straw-control. Baseline HR, BP, and HRV parameters were not different among the EC, the TC-D, and nonuser groups. In people who exclusively use ECs, acute nicotine-EC use increased HR and BP, and produced changes in HRV patterns suggestive of increased cardiac sympathetic influence. In people in the TC-D group, BP increased similarly after acutely smoking a nicotine-TC or a nicotine-EC. However, the increase in HR was significantly greater after smoking a TC compared with the nicotine-EC despite similar acute increases in plasma nicotine. Overall, all exposures containing nicotine significantly increased HR and BP in both cohorts when compared with non-nicotine exposures. Since acute EC use 1) produces an abnormal HRV pattern associated with increased cardiac sympathetic tone in people who chronically use ECs, and 2) similar hemodynamic increases compared with acute TC smoking in people who chronically smoke TCs including dual users, the role of ECs as part of a harm reduction strategy is questioned.NEW & NOTEWORTHY We found that nicotine, not the non-nicotine constituents in tobacco cigarette (TC) or electronic cigarette (EC) emissions, may be the instigator of the acute, potentially adverse, changes in hemodynamics and heart rate variability (HRV) that were recorded several minutes after tobacco product use. Furthermore, acute EC use produced an abnormal HRV pattern associated with increased cardiac risk in people who chronically smoke ECs and produced similar hemodynamic increases compared with acute TC use in people who chronically smoke TCs, including people who are dual users.