Abstract
Background/Objectives: Systematic quality review of ultrasound exams is recommended to ensure accurate diagnosis. Our primary objectives were to develop a quantitative method for quality review of estimated fetal weight (EFW) and to assess the accuracy of EFW for an entire practice and for individual personnel. A secondary objective was to evaluate the accuracy of fetal sex determination. Methods: This is a retrospective cohort study. Eligible ultrasound exams included singleton pregnancies with live birth and known birth weight (BW). A published method was used to predict BW from EFW for exams with ultrasound-to-delivery intervals of up to 12 weeks. Mean error and median absolute error (AE) were compared between different personnel. Image audits were performed for exams with AE > 30% and exams with reported fetal sex different than newborn sex. Results: We analyzed 1938 exams from 890 patients. In the last exam before birth, the median AE was 5.9%, and the predicted BW was within ±20% of the actual BW in 97.2% of patients. AE was >30% in 28 exams (1.4%); image audit found correct caliper placement in all 28. Only two patients (0.2%) had AE > 30% on the last exam before birth. One sonographer systematically over-measured head and abdominal circumferences, leading to EFWs that were overestimated. Reported fetal sex differed from newborn sex in seven exams (0.4%) and five patients (0.6%). Images in four of these patients were annotated with the correct fetal sex, but a clerical error was made in the report. In one patient, an unclear image was labeled "probably female", but the newborn was male. Conclusions: The accuracy of EFW in this practice was similar to literature reports. The quantitative analysis identified a sonographer with outlier measurements. Time-consuming image audits could be focused on a small number of exams with large errors. We suggest some enhancements to ultrasound reporting software that may help to reduce clerical errors. We provide tools to help other practices perform similar quality reviews.