Conclusion
The fibronectin adhesion assay does not appear to reliably isolate a chondroprogenitor cell population from nasoseptal cartilage, and these cells confer no advantageous properties for cartilage tissue engineering. Refinement of cell isolation methods and chondroprogenitor markers is warranted for future nasoseptal cartilage tissue engineering efforts.
Methods
Nasoseptal cartilage samples from 20 patients (10 male, 10 female) were digested to liberate cartilage-derived cells (CDCs) from extracellular matrix. Total cell number was counted using the Trypan Blue exclusion assay and added to fibronectin coated plates for 20 min, to determine the proportion of fibronectin-adherent (FAC) and non-adherent cells (NFACs). All populations underwent flow cytometry to detect mesenchymal stem/progenitor cell markers and were cultured in osteogenic, chondrogenic and adipogenic media to determine trilineage differentiation potential. Cell adherence and growth kinetics of the different populations were compared using iCELLigence growth assays. Chondrogenic gene expression was assessed using RT-qPCR for Type 2 collagen, aggrecan and SOX9 genes. Varying proportions of NFAC and FACs were cultured in alginate beads to assess tissue engineering potential.
Results
52.6% of cells were fibronectin adherent in males and 57.7% in females, yet on flow cytometrical analysis, only 0.19% of cells expressed CD49e. Moreover, all cells (CDC, FAC and NFACs) demonstrated an affinity for trilineage differentiation by first passage and the expression of stem/progenitor cell markers increased significantly from digest to first passage (CD29, 44, 49e, 73 and 90, p < 0.0001). No significant differences were seen in adhesion or growth rates. Collagen and aggrecan gene expression was higher in FACs than CDCs (2-fold higher, p = 0.008 and 0.012 respectively), but no differences in chondrogenic potential were seen in any cell mixtures in 3D culture models.