Glioblastoma (GBM) is defined by heterogeneous and resilient cell populations that closely reflect neurodevelopmental cell types. Although it is clear that GBM echoes early and immature cell states, identifying the specific developmental programmes disrupted in these tumours has been hindered by a lack of high-resolution trajectories of glial and neuronal lineages. Here we delineate the course of human astrocyte maturation to uncover discrete developmental stages and attributes mirrored by GBM. We generated a transcriptomic and epigenomic map of human astrocyte maturation using cortical organoids maintained in culture for nearly 2 years. Through this approach, we chronicled a multiphase developmental process. Our time course of human astrocyte maturation includes a molecularly distinct intermediate period that serves as a lineage commitment checkpoint upstream of mature quiescence. This intermediate stage acts as a site of developmental deviation separating IDH-wild-type neoplastic astrocyte-lineage cells from quiescent astrocyte populations. Interestingly, IDH1-mutant tumour astrocyte-lineage cells are the exception to this developmental perturbation, where immature properties are suppressed as a result of D-2-hydroxyglutarate oncometabolite exposure. We propose that this defiance is a consequence of IDH1-mutant-associated epigenetic dysregulation, and we identified biased DNA hydroxymethylation (5hmC) in maturation genes as a possible mechanism. Together, this study illustrates a distinct cellular state aberration in GBM astrocyte-lineage cells and presents developmental targets for experimental and therapeutic exploration.