Abstract
Microbial biofilms are a major hindrance in the wound healing process, prolonging the inflammatory response phase, thus making them a target in treatment. The aim of this study is to assess the antibacterial properties of commercially available wound dressings, of various material composition and antibacterial agents, towards multiple in vitro microbial and biofilm models. A variety of in vitro microbial and biofilm models were utilised to evaluate the ability of wound dressing materials to sequester microbes, prevent dissemination and manage bioburden. Sequestering and dissemination models were used to evaluate the ability of wound dressing materials to prevent the biofilm-forming bacterium, Pseudomonas aeruginosa, from migrating through dressing materials over a 24-72 h challenge period. Additionally, Centre for Disease Control (CDC) Bioreactor and Drip Flow models were used to evaluate antibacterial killing efficacy towards established P. aeruginosa and Staphylococcus aureus biofilms using more challenging, wound-like models. Controlled-release iodine foam and silver-impregnated carboxymethylcellulose (CMC) wound dressing materials demonstrated potent biofilm management properties in comparison to a methylene blue and gentian violet-containing foam dressing. Both the iodine-containing foam and silver-impregnated CMC materials effectively prevented viable P. aeruginosa dissemination for up to 72 h. In addition, the controlled-release iodine foam and silver-impregnated CMC materials reduced P. aeruginosa bioburden in the Drip Flow model. The controlled-release iodine foam demonstrated superiority in the CDC Bioreactor model, as both the silver- and iodine-containing materials reduced S. aureus to the limit of detection, but P. aeruginosa growth was only completely reduced by controlled-release iodine foam dressing materials. The data generated within the in vitro biofilm models supports the clinical data available in the public domain for the implementation of iodine foam dressings for effective biofilm management and control in wound care.