Background
Non-enveloped viruses, which lack a lipid envelope, display higher resistance to disinfectants, soaps and sanitizers compared to enveloped viruses. The capsids of these viruses are highly stable and symmetric protein shells that resist inactivation by commonly employed virucidal agents. This group of viruses include highly transmissible human pathogens such as Rotavirus, Poliovirus, Foot and Mouth Disease Virus, Norovirus and Adenovirus; thus, devising appropriate strategies for chemical disinfection is essential.
Conclusions
The distinct effects of the chemical treatment on the morphology of HAdV5 and FCV suggests that non-enveloped viruses with icosahedral geometry can follow different morphological pathways to inactivation. Synergistic effect of whole formulation is more effective compared to individual components. Molecular level understanding of inactivation pathways may result in the design and development of effective mass-market formulations for rapid neutralization of non-enveloped viruses.
Results
In this study, we tested a mild, hypoallergenic combination of a denaturant, alcohol, and organic acid (3.2% citric acid, 1% urea and 70% ethanol, pH4) on two representative non-enveloped viruses - Human Adenovirus 5 (HAdV5) and Feline Calicivirus (FCV)- and evaluated the pathways of capsid neutralization using biophysical methods. The conformational shifts in the capsid upon chemical treatment were studied using Differential Scanning Calorimetry (DSC), while the morphological alterations were visualized concurrently using Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM). We found that while treatment of purified HAdV5 particles with a formulation resulted in thermal instability and, large scale aggregation; similar treatment of FCV particles resulted in complete collapse of the capsids. Further, while individual components of the formulation caused significant damage to the capsids, a synergistic action of the whole formulation was evident against both non-enveloped viruses tested. Conclusions: The distinct effects of the chemical treatment on the morphology of HAdV5 and FCV suggests that non-enveloped viruses with icosahedral geometry can follow different morphological pathways to inactivation. Synergistic effect of whole formulation is more effective compared to individual components. Molecular level understanding of inactivation pathways may result in the design and development of effective mass-market formulations for rapid neutralization of non-enveloped viruses.