Abstract
Inferring the historical and biophysical causes of diversity within protein families is a complex puzzle. A key to unraveling this problem is characterizing the rugged topography of sequence-function adaptive landscapes. Using biochemical data from a 2(9) = 512 combinatorial library of tobacco 5-epi-aristolochene synthase (TEAS) mutants engineered to make the native major product of Egyptian henbane premnaspirodiene synthase (HPS) and a complementary 512 mutant HPS library, we address the question of how product specificity is controlled. These data sets reveal that HPS is far more robust and resistant to mutations than TEAS, where most mutants are promiscuous. We also combine experimental data with a sequence Potts Hamiltonian model and direct coupling analysis to quantify mutant fitness. Our results demonstrate that the Hamiltonian captures variation in product outputs across both libraries, clusters native family members based on their substrate specificities, and exposes the divergent catalytic roles of couplings between the catalytic and noncatalytic domains of TEAS versus HPS. Specifically, we found that the role of the interdomain connectivities in specifying product output is more important in TEAS than connectivities within the catalytic domain. Despite being 75% identical, this property is not shared by HPS, where connectivities within the catalytic domain are more important for specificity. By solving the X-ray crystal structure of HPS, we assessed structural bases for their interdomain network differences. Last, we calculate the product profile Shannon entropies of the two libraries, which showcases that site-site connectivities also play divergent roles in catalytic accuracy.