Abstract
Improving the precision of forest vegetation carbon stock estimation is essential for scientifically evaluating its economic value and ecological benefits. This study aims to investigate the impact of different estimation methods on carbon stock and its economic value. Taking the forest vegetation of the Zixi Mountain Nature Reserve as the research object, the carbon stock of the arbor layer was estimated using four approaches: the variable biomass expansion factor method, the biomass expansion factor method, the volume conversion method, and the continuous function method of the biomass conversion factor. The carbon stocks of economic forests and shrublands were estimated using the average biomass method. The economic value of forest carbon storage was then evaluated through the market value method and the optimal pricing approach for forest carbon sinks. The results revealed no significant differences among the four estimation methods. The estimated arbor forest carbon stocks were 692,548.39 tC, 672,599.83 tC, 673,161.07 tC, and 400,369.17 tC, respectively, with an overall average of 609,669.62 tC. The biomass expansion factor method and the volume conversion method produce the most consistent results. The corresponding relative errors were 13.59%, 10.32%, 10.41%, and -34.33%, respectively. The continuous function method of the biomass conversion factor exhibited the greatest variability, mainly due to the influence of Pinus yunnanensis parameters. Among all methods, the biomass expansion factor method yielded the smallest relative error, making it the most suitable for estimating arbor carbon stocks in the study area. The total average economic value of forest carbon storage in the region was estimated at CNY 58.09 million. Among all forest types, Pinus yunnanensis contributed the highest carbon value, totaling CNY 50.48 million. In terms of economic value per unit area, Pinus armandii ranked first, with CNY 11,418.92 per hectare. Among different age groups of arbor forests, middle-aged stands had the highest carbon sequestration value, reaching CNY 36.87 million. Across all functional zones, the core zone showed the greatest economic value at CNY 29.34 million. Enhancing forest resource protection to maximize both carbon sink capacity and economic returns, as well as promoting forest carbon trading, can bring additional economic benefits to Southwest China while contributing to the achievement of the national "dual carbon" goals.