Abstract
Tau pathology underlies a broad spectrum of neurodegenerative disorders, collectively termed tauopathies, yet these diseases exhibit striking heterogeneity in their biological mechanisms and clinical outcomes. The basis for this heterogeneity remains poorly understood. Here, we address this question using knock-in mouse models expressing two distinct frontotemporal dementia-associated tau mutations to define how different tau variants drive divergent pathogenic programs in vivo . We find that the two mutations give rise to fundamentally different trajectories of tau pathogenesis. One trajectory is marked by progressive tau hyperphosphorylation and cytoskeletal destabilization occurring in the absence of detectable tau seed formation. In contrast, an alternative trajectory is characterized by tau hypophosphorylation, early seed formation, and alterations in nucleotide metabolism and chromatin organization, without overt cytoskeletal disruption. With aging, tau in this latter pathway transitions to a hyperphosphorylated state and forms mature fibrillar aggregates. Genetic enhancement of β-amyloid selectively accelerates fibril formation, particularly in the model exhibiting early seeding. Together, these findings demonstrate that distinct tau mutations can engage separable pathogenic mechanisms, providing a biological framework for the heterogeneity observed across tauopathies, and highlighting the need for mechanism-informed therapeutic strategies and patient stratification. GRAPHICAL ABSTRACT: Schematic representation comparing two trajectories of tau pathology. The S305N mutation promotes a 4R isoform shift, cytoskeletal damage and synapse loss, and accumulation of soluble hyperphosphorylated tau. Tau remains soluble even at old ages. In contrast, the P301S mutation generates hypophosphorylated, seed-competent tau that forms fibrils. The effect of amyloid is slow in the S305N, but results in accelerated acceleration of pathology in the P301S. Figure made with Biorender.com .